Reliability Solutions for the Aerospace Industry
Powerful solutions for high-performing components

Reliability Solutions for the Airline Industry
Reliability solutions that make your profits soar

Reliability Solutions for the Automotive Industry
Reliability from R&D to the road

Reliability Solutions for the Chemical and Process Industry
Build processes with reliable results

Reliability Solutions for the Defense Industry
A strong reliability program breeds strong defense

Reliability Solutions for the Electronics and Appliances Industry
Reliable components ensure reliable business

Reliability Solutions for the Energy Industry
Let reliability light the way

Reliability Solutions for the IT Hardware
Reliability keeps the world connected

Reliability Solutions for the Medical and Healthcare Industry
Reliability for life

Reliability Solutions for Military Organizations
Dependability begins with reliability

Reliability Solutions for the Oil and Gas Industry
Streamline processes along the pipeline

Reliability Solutions for the Semiconductor Industry
Big results for small materials

Reliability Solutions for the Telecommunications Industry
Reliable solutions to better help you connect the world

Reliability Solutions for the Transportation Industry
Results that get you where you need to be

Reliability Solutions for the Trucks and Heavy Equipment
Reliability solutions that do the heavy lifting

Ordering Software from ReliaSoft
Choose the software license and configuration that's best fit for your organization

The Synthesis Platform
Integration to Empower the Reliability Organization

ALTA — Accelerated Life Testing Data Analysis Software
Accelerated life tests... quantifiable resultsTM

RENO — Simulation Software for Probabilistic Event and Risk Analysis
If you can flowchart it, you can simulate itTM

RBI — Risk Based Inspection (RBI) Software
Full-featured RCM with risk based inspection

ReliaSoft Offers Unparalleled Technical Support and Documentation
Connect with ReliaSoft's acclaimed technical support team via phone, email and live chat at locations throughout the world

The Synthesis Enterprise Portal
Open up the Synthesis Platform, and your work in the platform, to your whole organization with this web-based Portal

DOE++ — Software Tool for Experiment Design and Analysis (DOE)
DOE software designed with reliability in mindTM

Lambda Predict — Standards Based Reliability Prediction Software
MIL-217 * Bellcore/Telcordia * FIDES * NSWC Mechanical

MPC — MSG-3 Aircraft Maintenance Program Creation Software
An MSG-3 compliant maintenance program creator

Register and Activate Software from ReliaSoft
Start using ReliaSoft's helpful applications by registering and activating your software today!

The Synthesis API
Application Programming Interfaces (APIs) for the Synthesis Platform

RGA — Reliability Growth Analysis and Repairable System Analysis
Reliability growth and repairable system analysisTM

Xfmea — FMEA and FMECA Software Tool
Expert support for all types of FMEA and FMECATM

XFRACAS — Web-Based Failure Reporting Software (FRACAS System)
Highly configurable, web-based FRACAS

Download Free Software Demos and Free Service Releases
Get a free trial of the reliability engineering software trusted by thousands of companies, or install the latest update

Weibull++ — Life Data Analysis (Weibull Analysis) Software
The standard for reliability life data analysisTM

BlockSim — System Reliability and Maintainability Analysis Software
The ultimate system visualization and analysis toolTM

RCM++ — Reliability Centered Maintenance (RCM) Software
Putting the reliability back into reliability centered maintenanceTM

Orion eAPI — Enterprise System Focused on Asset Performance Management
Reliability Business IntelligenceTM

Reliability Education Course List
Peruse the variety of introductory and advanced courses offered for reliability practitioners of all experience levels

The New Master the Subject, Master the Tools!SM Course Lineup
Choose the reliability engineering education track that best fits your needs: Product Development or Asset Management

Worldwide Public Seminar Calendar
Find out which courses are being taught near you, and register today!

Why Attend ReliaSoft's Reliability Training Seminars?
Learn about ReliaSoft's commitment to reliability engineering education, as well as the benefits of attending

Seminar Registration
Register for a course today, and learn about seminar options and other details

Seminar Instructors
Meet the esteemed group of professionals that bring ReliaSoft's training seminars to life

Reliability Training Center (RTC)
Take a glimpse inside ReliaSoft's newly built, multimillion dollar state-of-the-art training facility

Frequently Asked Questions about ReliaSoft's Seminars
Get answers to the most common questions about the finer details of attending ReliaSoft's courses

Available Reliability Consulting Services
ReliaSoft's expert consulting team can accommodate requests of any size or complexity in a wide variety of areas

Customers that Benefited from ReliaSoft's Consulting Services
View some of the organizations that took advantage of ReliaSoft's on-site consulting and education services

ReliaSoft's Expert Reliability Consultants
Meet the esteemed group of professionals that organizations worldwide have trusted for their consulting needs

Frequently Asked Questions about ReliaSoft's Consulting Services
Get answers to the most common questions about the finer details of ReliaSoft's consulting services

About ReliaSoft Corporation
Learn more about ReliaSoft and its commitment to empowering the reliability professional

ReliaSoft Corporation Online Store
Purchase new software licenses, upgrades or resource books, and register for training seminars or ARS events

Companies that Rely on ReliaSoft's Reliability Software and Services
See some of the hundreds of companies that look to ReliaSoft for the tools necessary to power their reliability programs

Press Releases
Read about the latest exciting ReliaSoft product releases and announcements

Print-Ready Publications and Media Links
Browse for publications and videos relating to ReliaSoft's products and services

Career Opportunities at ReliaSoft Corporation
Want to work for the leading provider of reliability engineering software tools and services? Check for openings today!

How to Contact ReliaSoft Corporation
ReliaSoft offers unparalleled phone, e-mail and live chat support at locations throughout the world

ReliaSoft Customer Testimonials
"Amazing," "User Friendly," "Cutting Edge..." See what people are saying about ReliaSoft's software!

Weibull.com
The most complete website devoted entirely to the topic of reliability engineering, theory, data analysis and modeling

ReliaSoft.tv
A multimedia resource portal for both users of our software tools as well as all reliability engineering professionals

Synthesis Applications eDocuments & ePublications Library
Access useful support documents for ReliaSoft's Synthesis Applications, including user's guides and reference books

ReliaWiki
A resource portal and a wiki for professionals in reliability engineering and related fields

Certified Reliability Professional (CRP)
Distinguishing reliability engineers who have gained and successfully demonstrated unquestionable expertise in the field

International Applied Reliability Symposium (ARS)
Sharing applications, success stories and lessons learned in reliability and maintainability engineering

Reliability Discussion Forum
Connect, discuss and share with the reliability engineering community

Reliability Edge Newsletter
In-depth articles on reliability engineering theories and principles, as well as ReliaSoft updates

Reliability HotWire
Your source of information and tips on how to improve your reliability practices

Volume 4, Issue 2

Reliability Edge Home

Physics of Failure for Making High Reliability a Reality

Guest Submission

Thomas Stadterman, Ph.D.
David Mortin, Ph.D.
U.S. Army Materiel Systems Analysis Activity (AMSAA)

The Army's Aberdeen Proving Ground (APG), located in Harford County, Maryland, is home to a diverse array of laboratories and centers that spearhead military research and development, test and evaluation, and science and engineering. In addition to military endeavors, these centers are actively involved with helping solve complex problems in engineering design, tests and analyses for the commercial and industrial sectors.

The U.S. Army Materiel Systems Analysis Activity (AMSAA) is one of these APG centers. AMSAA and a team of leading engineering and analysis organizations continue to expand physics-of-failure technology applications to Department of Defense weapon systems to improve reliability and reduce costs. Physics of failure is an engineering-based approach to reliability that uses modeling and simulation to eliminate failures early in the design process by addressing root-cause failure mechanisms in a Computer-Aided- Engineering environment. This approach is proving essential for meeting Army and Department of Defense (DoD) transformation objectives.

Figure 1: Stryker

Figure 1: Mechanical Simulations International developed the dynamic simulation of the Stryker, which produces the force and acceleration time history of the vehicle traversing terrain. This information will be used in the suspension component fatigue analysis

The physics-of-failure approach proactively incorporates reliability into the design process by establishing a scientific basis for evaluating new materials, structures and electronics technologies. Information to plan tests and screens and to determine electrical and thermo-mechanical stress margins are identified by the approach. Physics of failure encourages innovative, cost-effective design through the use of realistic reliability assessment. Generic failure models are used by physics of failure, which are as effective for new materials and structures as they are for existing designs. This approach involves the following (Cushing et al, 1993):

  • Identifying potential failure mechanisms (chemical, electrical, physical, mechanical, structural or thermal processes leading to failure); failure sites; and failure modes.
     
  • Identifying the appropriate failure models and their input parameters, including those associated with material characteristics, damage properties, relevant geometry at failure sites, manufacturing flaws and defects, and environmental and operating loads.
     
  • Determining the variability for each design parameter when possible.
     
  • Computing the effective reliability function.
     
  • Accepting the design, if the estimated time-dependent reliability function meets or exceeds the required value over the required time period.

A central feature of the physics-of-failure approach is that reliability modeling, which is used for the detailed design of electronic equipment, is based on root-cause failure processes or mechanisms. These failure-mechanism models explicitly address the design parameters which have been found to influence hardware reliability strongly, including material properties, defects and electrical, chemical, thermal and mechanical stresses. The goal is to keep the modeling in a particular application as simple as possible without losing the cause-effect relationships, which benefits corrective action. Research into physical failure mechanisms is subjected to scholarly peer review and published in the open literature. The failure mechanism models are validated through experimentation and replication by multiple researchers (Cushing et al, 1993).

Physics-of-failure analyses have been successfully performed for many DoD systems resulting in improved reliability and millions of dollars in savings. Electronics have been analyzed in numerous systems including radar ground stations, hand-held monitors, helicopters, tracked vehicles, wheeled vehicles, power supplies and missiles. Mechanical structures have been analyzed on Army trailers, floating bridges, dry bridges and wheeled vehicles. Reliability improvements were applied to many of these systems, which resulted in fewer field failures and significant cost benefits.

One of the many examples of physics-of-failure success was for commercial-off-the-shelf (COTS) circuit cards used in a wheeled-vehicle system. The AMSAA analysis showed that the COTS circuit cards could be used in the system without reducing system reliability, which decreased the acquisition costs of the electronics by $12,000 per circuit card and over $1 million during initial production. Another analysis was performed on a tri-service radio, which identified a failure mechanism that would cause the radio to fail repeatedly (Osterman and Stadterman, 1999). Different components were used to remove this failure mechanism. The estimated operating and support cost avoidance was $27 million due to elimination of transportation, repair and spare parts associated with the failures. AMSAA is currently performing analysis on electronics used in missile, helicopter and tracked-vehicle systems.

Figure 2: University of Maryland CALCE software

Figure 2: University of Maryland CALCE software was used to calculate the displacement of circuit cards during vibration. This information was used to estimate component life

In addition to electronics, the tools have been applied to Army bridging systems. AMSAA has served as the Accreditation Agent for physical simulation undertaken to address bridge durability. In this capacity, AMSAA monitored the physical simulation and validation activities, reviewed the data, and performed independent physics-of-failure analyses to quantify the levels of fatigue imposed in the bridge structures from both the real world and simulated events. For a floating bridge, results of the analysis were used to avoid a lengthy retest and to support an Urgent Materiel Release for fielding to Iraq. Estimated savings from this analysis was $2 million.

An Army team including representatives from the Universities of Iowa and Tennessee performed a comprehensive physics-of-failure analysis on an Army trailer experiencing fatigue failures (Stadterman et al, 2003). The analysis represented the first documented use of an integrated process of testing for model inputs, dynamic simulation to produce loads, extensive validation testing and fatigue analysis. Results from this analysis indicated that the trailer drawbar would experience fatigue failures after use on cross-country terrain. Using University of Iowa software, an optimized design based on weight and fatigue life was developed for the drawbar. If this analysis had been performed during design, millions of dollars of redesign and test cost could have been avoided.

Figure 3: Trailer

Figure 3: The solid model of the trailer was used to develop the dynamic simulation model and the finite element model used in the physics-of-failure analysis

Physics of failure continues to be an award-winning initiative that will allow the DoD to reduce logistics footprint and produce military platforms with the high levels of reliability that our soldiers deserve. Additional information is available on the Web at https://stb.apg.army.mil/BDO/.

References
Cushing, M., D. Mortin, T. Stadterman and A. Malhotra (1993). "Comparison of Electronics-
     Reliability Assessment Approaches," IEEE Transactions on Reliability, Vol. 42, No. 1,
     December.

Stadterman, T., W. Connon, K. Choi, J. Freeman and A. Peltz (2003). "Dynamic Modeling and
     Durability Analyses from the Ground Up," Journal of the IEST, Vol. 46.

Osterman, M. and T. Stadterman (1999). "Failure Assessment Software for Circuit Card
     Assemblies," Proceedings for the Annual Reliability and Maintainability Symposium.

End Article

 

About the Authors
Thomas Stadterman is the Physics-of-Failure Development Team Leader for the U.S. Army Materiel Systems Analysis Activity. He conducts and manages research on applying physics-of-failure and prognostic concepts to military systems. He has a Ph.D. and M.S. in Reliability Engineering from the University of Maryland, an M.S. in Administration from Central Michigan University and a B.S. in Electrical Engineering from the University of Pittsburgh.

Dr. David E. Mortin is Chief of the Reliability Branch at the U.S. Army Materiel Systems Analysis Activity. He has a Ph.D. in Reliability Engineering from the University of Maryland, an M.S. in Statistics from the University of Delaware and a B.S. in Aerospace Engineering from the State University of New York at Buffalo.

The authors can be reached by e-mail at stad@amsaa.army.mil.

 

ReliaSoft.com Footer

Copyright © 1992 - 2015 ReliaSoft Corporation. All Rights Reserved
Privacy Statement | Terms of Use | Site Map | Contact | About Us    ReliaSoft on Facebook  ReliaSoft on Twitter  ReliaSoft on LinkedIn  ReliaSoft on Google+